7 of Our Favorite Old-Fashioned Goodies

Old-Fashioned Goodies include cookies and lemon bars

We’re certain the best way to make guests feel at home is with a plateful of homemade confections—along with a tall glass of sweet tea. Browse seven of our favorite old-fashioned goodies sure to make your friends and family smile.


1. Classic Tea Cakes

Old-Fashioned Goodies Tea Cakes served in a white linen-lined silver dishServe these citrus-kissed tea cakes for afternoon get-togethers with close companions. They pair perfectly with a hot beverage or a cool glass of milk.

Blue and white graphic that reads "View Recipe"

2. Benne Wafers

Old-Fashioned Goodies Benne Wafers served in a white perforated dish and topped with small yellow flowersOld-fashioned goodies like these never go out of vogue. Bring these tasty treats to any gathering for a bit of nostalgia.

Blue and white graphic that reads "View Recipe"

3. Orange Date Pinwheels

Old-Fashioned Goodies Orange Date Pinwheels served in a silver dish and 2 set on an embroidered linenThese buttery bite-size snacks are packed with the classic flavors of zesty orange and sweet dates.

Blue and white graphic that reads "View Recipe"

4. Lemon Chess Bars

Old-Fashioned Goodies Lemon Chess Bars served on a round wire rackIs there anything more delightful than fresh-baked lemon bars? This recipe always pleases a crowd.

Blue and white graphic that reads "View Recipe"

5. Pecan Pie Thumbprint Cookies

Old-Fashioned Goodies Pecan Pie Thumbprint Cookies served on a wooden cutting boardIn a tiny bite, these pecan-studded cookies pack abundant flavor. They also make for a wonderful gift year-round.

Blue and white graphic that reads "View Recipe"

6. Strawberry Rhubarb Crumble Bars

Old-Fashioned Goodies Strawberry Rhubard Crumble Bars on a blue rectangular trayA traditional pairing of fresh strawberry and rhubarb create these tantalizing crumble bars.

Blue and white graphic that reads "View Recipe"

7. Sorghum Spice Cookies

Old-Fashioned Goodies Sorghum Spice Cookies served on a striped tray next to floral tea cupsA little sugar and a hint of spice go a long way—and these gooey sorghum-laced cookies prove it.

Blue and white graphic that reads "View Recipe"


Discover seasonal recipes, inspiring style ideas, and more by ordering your Southern Lady print subscription and digital subscription today!

Southern Lady January/February 2024 cover with "Subscribe Today" text